H1Base….in my opinion

Other Sites

Its funny while I am writing this post I have a chat window open for Live Chat Support at H1Base which tells me I have 0 people in front of me and I have 1 minute wait time, yet nobody comes.

I don’t recommend these people or company in any way or whatever it claims to be and this is the reason why and if you have a different story, please feel free to share in the comments section. They are complete frauds in what they proport to guarantee for you or in the amount of service they offer.

Before I first moved to the US to live 3 years ago, I like you was lost and did searches online and H1Base came up in the paid listing in Google along with numerous other people proporting to help you get a work visa (for a fee of course!).

Now after browsing through most of them H1Base seemed the most reputable as it provided genuinely helpful information and didn’t ask to charge you the moment you entered the site as most others did. Additionaly the US Diversety Visa Lottery (or Green Card Lottery as it is more commonly known) run by the US State Department was mentioned on there as a simple form you could complete yourself to enter. This is entirely true, it takes all of 5 minutes and is as basic as a form could be and is FREE to enter. However many sites charge a fee to do this for you, claiming all sorts of things and difficulties you may have.
To me the only difficulty you could possibly haveĀ  is if you can’t read or speak English. However if that is your issue you wouldn’t be able to understand the site asking for your money anyway :)

So I digress, H1Base seemed reputable. It had as one of their offerings at the time and still does when I look at the site a guaranteed job finding service that will not stop until they secure you a H1B visa job (or E3) and you get your visa. On the face of it that sounds awesome given the relatively low price you have to pay (currently under $200USD) but has one major flaw. Ultimately regardless of whether they even do find you a job, there are a few bridges to cross.

Firstly the USCIS (US Customs and Immigration Service) formerly known as the INS (not required forand Department of Labor have to approve separate petitions of the company willing to employ you and pay relevant costs.

If you pass that hurdle then you have the significant hurdle of the Quota for H1B (there is a quota for E3 too although has yet to filled in any year it has been running). H1B applications open each year on April 1 and the last 2 years at least they received in excess of 100,000 application on that first day alone.
So you can see instantly there is an issue. There is huge demand and even if you have ticked every box 100% successfully up to this point you can still lose out here very easily because there is an element of luck involved. Granted there are things that can help having a US Masters Degree or higher (which would have most likely cost you a lot already) which puts you under a different cap, working for an approvedĀ  non-profit/government/education institution which are often uncapped, paying the Premium Filing Fee (an extra $1,000) to help expidite your case and have access to your case officer by phone, etc. but in the end this is still out of yours (and H1Base’s hands).

Finally you have to be approved by the US Consulate that you apply too and you can be rejected there for a whole host of reasons either because of something to do with you or the company or both. Consulate’s are funny entities and can operate completely differently depending on the city or country you apply. Generally if you have paid all the fees, you haven’t lied about anything yourself, there is no criminal history, the company documents and fees are in order, etc. you should be fine but there are certainly no guarantees.

So H1Base claim of guarantee of a job and a visa does not mean much when they have no say over 95% of the process!

Now the suspicious aspect of this all for me is that (by the way I am still waiting for that live chat support I mentioned at the beginning) when I was in Australia and I emailed them asking for help, they answered all my questions quickly and fully and seemed very friendly. When I moved to the US initially under a J1 visa and was looking for a permanent work position and contacted them for help via email mentioning I was in Boston, I never once got a response.

Given I was in the US I also thought I would call their numbers as well but the numerous times I tried during normal business hours (given they are supposedly based in Florida and same timezone as me) i went through an endless look of automated answering options and no matter what options I picked I always ended up at a voicemail at the end. Very Suspicious I Think!!

When you look at their site they supposedly have recommendations from Monster and CNN and Universities and maybe its true and maybe it isn’t or it has been taken out of context but I’ll bet if those insitutions knew about my experiences they may think twice about their comments.

Anyway I will be back soon again for more help….but otherwise Happy Searching!

CJ (still no response from their Live Chat…surprise, surprise!)

P.S. as a side note, read one of their ridiculous newsletter headlines and then obvious comments from someone from the below the post (even though he can’t admit it

Share and Enjoy:
  • Print
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Mixx
  • Google Bookmarks
  • IndianPad
  • LinkedIn
  • MySpace
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter
  • Yahoo! Buzz
11 Comments

11 Comments

  1. Rakesh Jain  •  May 28, 2009 @7:49 pm

    just a question:

    did you use their service ? – I mean are you really speaking from first hand experience OR is it as you say just a personal opinion and assumption because they didnt answer your enquiry

    I really need an H1B to stay in USA or I have to go back home, and I’ve had bad luck trying the on Yahoo and Monster, and I’ve sent to lots of companies you list on your site (thank), but no results from anything and a lot of the companies you list don’t sponsor this year anymore so i need up to date information if you have some ?

    I ask because a friend signed up with them 2 days ago and they are re-writing her resume now and she likes them, and says they are next going to send her resume to hundreds of employers for her that registered with them this year (not last years list).

    so I’m not sure about it all and I hope you understand I need real facts (not opinions) to do whats best for me and my family, if you bought there service and had a real experience using it then thats different, but if you have not used there service and its just a personal opinion you have, it should not be good to lead me away from a possible good chance I have.

    you said you do the same thing as them for free – so can i send my resume to you to re-write it and you send it to lots of this years sponsor employers for me and keep doing it for me for a few months ?

    Thanks
    Rak.

    Also, i can’t see any mention of a guarantee on their site. They say they help get a job but they dont make any claim to guarantee a visa (dont know why you said that as there’s nothing there). But they do have a different service to help employers file visas with USCIS, is that it.

  2. admin  •  May 29, 2009 @9:28 pm

    Hi Rakesh,
    Haha it is amazing how people try hard to make stuff up. Is it because your traffic has gone down so far or is it beacause when you type in Google “h1base scam” there are endless results and people’s bad experiences. I guess the generic post that you did on my other H1Base post that I have seen you do on numeorus other sites pretending to be someone else doesn’t fly anymore so you try and put an Indian name and a different type of post.
    The truth is you probably made so much money a few years ago but with people being smarter, more info being available on the Internet and H1B numbers so far down in 2009, you are just desperate for revenue. The good news is people aren’t so gullable anymore :)
    Do you know how ridiculous your comments sound?
    Look read real comments on the site and you see when people make comments they talk about specific things but don’t talk about things like they are promoting a product.
    Your “friend” must be really stupid if they paid H1Base hundreds of dollars or whatever ridiculous amount of money to rewrite a resume. You can find so many free examples on the Internet and hey get someone on Craigslist to do it for you for $10 if you are that incompetent.
    If you need “real facts” about H1Base then why are you so concerned about an article titled “H1Base, In my opinion.
    The best thing about you writing this comment is that it is now here for more people to read when they search on Google to really see how much of a SCAM your site is and the attempts their owners go to pretend the products are legitimate. Then they can go to the British Expat forums or any other Immigration forum and read the same thing from many many people.
    The fundamental difference between my site and yours is that I try to help people with my posts and plainly state that I don’t have all the answers but hope this helps people in their quest. You exploit people by charging them hundreds of dollars for a service and guarantees you can’t back up.
    1. You can’t guarantee a job to anyone b/c you don’t hire people.
    2. If you could guarantee jobs, don’t you think in this economy everyone would flock to you. Obviously people don’t b/c you can’t
    3. Yes the list of employers I provided to help was last year’s as that is all that is avaliable. The Department of Labor hasn’t released this year’s list as the season is not over. The truth is that most if not all those employers are hiring H1Bs still (barring the TARP and bailout companies) just in far smaller numbers

    If there is one positive to come from this bad economy it is the hope the companies like yours cease to exist to exploit foreigners who have a hard enough road as it is.

    As I said thanks again for your comment it only helps me in my attempt to prove how bad your site is and how H1Base is a SCAM in my opinion.

    CJ

    PS. As I can see what IP Address people post comments from, it is amazing that “Steven” who posted on my other H1Base blog post has the same IP address as you :)

  3. Rakesh Jain  •  May 31, 2009 @11:39 pm

    I only ask a couple of quick and simple questions, and said my own opinions and comments about a some very questionable opinions and comments you have made.

    and you threw your last reply back in my face with insults, accusations and false comments which were uncalled for and way out there!

    so, if I cut through your illegal activities, cover up and insults and get to the real truth – what you are really saying is this:

    1) you did Not use there services – so I can not believe anything you say about them.

    2) you have No real experience with the company but you make lots of false claims about them – I can’t see anywhere that they say they guarantee a visa like you say (anyone can check that) – so I can not trust your word

    I’ve seen loads of your spam reviews in lots of different places (most out there about this company are all written by You) – but the truth is you never even used there services, and, they don’t claim a guarantee visa — so your review posts are all false, misleading, unethical and very suspicious!! (maybe as someone else said, its because on all the posts you’ve made everywhere you always in some form deliberately market your own site – I guess this is a new form of desperate marketing)

    What I really get out of all this is – all your personal opinions, assumptions and false comments are worthless – just words with nothing real and no proof behind them, which makes me question your honesty and credibility.

    Your nothing more than a common criminal by publicly and illegally slandering a company. If I did have anything to do with this company you would have been sued a long time ago. It’s not my job to tell them but I am sure they will find out at some time. I don’t want anything to do with criminals. so this will be the last time I ever come to you or your site (and if you tracked my IP you will know I’m thousands of miles away from where they are in Florida!!)

    Your best advice and all you can offer me is;
    1) for a resume re-write service is to pay someone $10 on Caigslist — what r u on??, what rubbish will I get for $10 bucks!!. When I look at professional resume writing services on the internet they all charge $50-$200 (some are even more than that!!)

    2) use your list of completely out-of-date companies that sponsored visas over 14 months ago (are you aware of whats happened with the economy / companies / employment market over the last year!!).

    You claim on your site that you do ‘exactly the same’ as they do for Free – well, I took you up on your word and I now know that its a complete lie (all you really do for free is list a bunch of Old company names, which after spending a lot of my time and effort found out aren’t even sponsoring at the moment – its was useless help!).

    Underneath your mask you will say and do anything for your own personal benefit (thats not what people really want – people need the ‘whole’ truth and the real truth so we can make proper informed decisions, not decisions based on what you have now shown to be nothing more than a worthless opinion and masquerade.

    After my unfortunate time with you, my feeling is that you write like the media does – you just make things up and twist stories around, and do your best to Not telling the whole truth. I came here to ask a couple of simple questions, and one way or another I got the answers (but not in the way I expected). Your unprofessional behaviour (especially as you owner of this site) has made my mind up to go with my feeling and seek proper help rather than from someone who acts like you and gives bad advice.

    You have lost respect in you and I hope more people can see through you for what and who you really are. Now I realize you are unethically, unprofessionally and acted illegally, and after reading your response and insults, and using your useless services, and your disgraceful attitude towards people.

    Good bye and good luck. Sooner or later the real truth always surfaces and people like you always get what they deserve!!

    Rak.

    PS. I definately won’t ever returning here, so you can go ahead and post another one of your cover up story you want.

  4. admin  •  Jun 1, 2009 @6:48 pm

    Hi “Rakesh” or “Steven” or whatever alias you want today,
    If you came on here and correctly identified yourself as a member of H1Base and stated your case I would have respect for you. Since you make up fake names and pretend to be an advocate in such an obvious way, how can I respect such deception.
    Noone who reads your comments will think you are real customer as not even the most ardent Apple entusiasts on their forums spends as much time defending a company as you have here.
    I encourage all who read these comment posts to judge for yourself and I hope you keep your money in your own pocket and devote it to the already excessive consulate visa applications fees, airline fees, relocation fees and all other costs you have to endure to live and work in the US.
    Hey call H1Base’s phone number and email them your detailed questions as everyone’s situation is unique and see how good the replies are.
    Ask yourself when you go to Monster.com or directly to companies and apply for jobs and go through their 30min application process answering questions and filling in personal details, how anyone could do that for you 100 times and more over.
    In the end it is your life and you can believe sites like H1Base and see the people who represent them from their comments here or you can trust your own judgement and research and keep your money in your own pocket.
    CJ

  5. Rakesh Jain  •  Jun 3, 2009 @1:08 am

    Hi Admin (CJ)

    this is RAKESH and here’s my real honest thoughts as a viewer:

    1) for some weird reason you seem to spend more and more time spam-trashing a company that you really have NO experience with (it’s just your ‘opinion’ and ‘assumptions’ – which I appreciate, but now honestly can’t really pay much attention to on this matter because you seem to be taking it all too personally and emotionally – you’ve even dedicated your home page and almost most of your recent life to it – as I said before, it doesn’t make sense to me when you haven’t even used their services). Is this really your true character and how you react – make such extreme emotional based actions and comments for No ‘real’ reason (it has to make me logically think you have an alterior motive!).

    2) I came here originaly for your open opinions on US immigration as you write well – not to continually keep reading and hearing the same old boring stuff

    3) I really don’t care if you personally like them or don’t like them. Thats not what your site is meant to 100% focus on (which you and it seems to be doing right now – the same old same old gets boring very fast)

    4) I don’t like the way you react in such a personally offensive way when people make comments on your site – I hoped you would provide support – not insults and accusations to me.

    H1bas obviously has helped many people, and we all know there’s no 100% guarantee – but what you should do is not tell people things purely based on what you ‘think’ without any facts or real experience to back it up — we all know getting an H1B is a life changing experience and is not simple in any means. Although some people (like you) find it easy many people like me don’t. You shouldn’t destroy what may be “my” best opportunity (I didn’t mean to trash your company lists but they didn’t work for “me” – and I now need more help than that).

    Just be honest and I and others will respect you more and follow you. I’ve done a lot of research since your 1st response to me and lots of people who need extra help really like them and they do help people (and so does my friend – and she asked me tell you that she is NOT stupid :) ).

    Release your ego and personal ‘emotional’ opinions and start show you really want to work with and help people. It’s a much better way to achieve peace, harmony and success in the short life we have.

    I wish you good luck.
    Rak.

    PS – can you start giving a direct email and telephone number on your site anytime soon?

  6. admin  •  Jun 3, 2009 @8:27 am

    Hi again “Rakesh”…why don’t you try a different name this time as then you can show more people like H1Base :)

    Like I said in my last comment, I am glad you keep commenting as it makes it ever more obvious to someone who visits this site what H1Base is really about and the nature of people who run it.

    When I first wrote about H1Base I was just skeptical about their offering but given that unlike many other unscrupulous sites didn’t participate in the Green Card Lottery scams thought maybe there is some legitimate component to them. It is only over time after hearing feedback and especially now with your comment posts “Rakesh” and “Steven” that I realized the true nature of the site.

    The fundamental difference between this site and H1Base is we don’t charge for anything as all this is here is blog of information with community discussion. That is a big difference from a service charging people like H1Base. If this were a business charging people for information, help or products, then we would have a phone number and location.

    In the end you can continue to say whatever you want “Rakesh” but in the end it is not up to me or you to determine anything. It will be the readers who decide whether your site H1Base is a scam or a service they want to pay a lot of their hard earned money for.

    CJ

  7. ******stupidadmin  •  Nov 1, 2009 @6:35 pm

    Admin comments are really dumb and worthless. I am going with RAKESH statements and he is abosultely right about you. YOU HAVE NOT USED THEIR SERVICE THEN HOW THE HELL CAN YOU COMMENT. GET A LIFE YOU MORON.

  8. e3visa  •  Nov 1, 2009 @8:21 pm

    Hi ***stupidadmin,
    Clearly your rational arguments are so convincing :) The fact that you don’t realize Rakesh is actually H1Base shows that you must be H1Base as well. Like I always say keep coming back here to post as it only means all the people here who read the comments will only be more convinced about what H1Base really is.
    Thanks again,
    CJ

  9. Jono  •  Jan 27, 2010 @11:52 pm

    Heh, I am sure that ******stupidadmin is also Rakesh.

    I plan to have a looksie around your site, as I am keen to get myself into the US (very sick of little old New Zealand!) Do you have any advice on where to start?

    I too have looked at H1Base, and plan to have a better look around their site, just in case, but I am always a little sceptical of companies with poor website design (being a web dev myself!) Hence googling and eventually finding your site.

    Cheers!

    Jono

  10. e3visa  •  Jan 31, 2010 @5:04 pm

    Hi Jono,
    Look H1Base does provide a legitimate value added service, and my original point in the post was that people should be aware that they don’t have control over the process so can’t back up their guarantees and that there are free and cheaper resources available for most things they offer as a service.
    However from their various comments on a couple of different pages on the site, I wanted to leave unedited so people can make a fully informed view on the type of company they are dealing with.
    Yes the US is a great country to work in with far more options than most. However don’t forget your country is without a doubt the most beautiful in the world :)
    A good place to start for someone from New Zealand would be (http://e3visa.info/2009/03/10/what-is-the-h-1b-visa-how-do-i-get-one-now/) and (http://e3visa.info/2009/01/19/which-are-the-best-places-to-find-a-job/)
    Good Luck,
    CJ

  11. Karine  •  Jul 4, 2010 @10:27 pm

    Hi CJ,

    I have read the little argument between you and Rakesh and i am not sure what to do. I am currently a student in the US looking to work here after graduation. I am currently a basic member of H1Base so i can see the job listing. It was $75/6 months but I wanted to check it out before I paid a full $250. Anyways- i was looking to take their 250 service because they say they will apply to jobs for you (only sending resume to sponsoring companies).

    After reading all this I am not sure if I should do it but here is my question:

    Do you know any other site that can help me find sponsored jobs? I have a list of the sponsoring companies this year (since I am a member for another 3-4 months) but I seem to have no luck in receiving replies for work. My resume is not half bad, i have experience in different fields but I am wondering if I am doing something wrong.

    The only thing about H1Base that I can say I don’t like so far is that their job listing is from many website (climber.com, careerbuilder…) so I am not sure if the listed openings are actually sponsoring.

    Anyways- I just want to find a NO scam company that would actually help me find a job (like a job hunter for international students)

    Thanks

    Karine

Leave a Reply

Allowed tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>